Advice

BARF diet for dogs: benefits, risks and precautions.

In brief.

  • The BARF diet for dogs is a diet based on raw meat, meaty bones, offal and a small share of plant foods, prepared at home or bought ready-made.
  • Its supporters credit it with many benefits, but studies confirm only one: slightly better digestibility than some dry foods.
  • Raw meat can carry bacteria that are dangerous to the dog and to the whole family: in a Dutch study, more than half of the commercial BARF products analysed contained Listeria.
  • Home-made BARF rations are often unbalanced: 60% of the rations studied in Germany had at least one imbalance in minerals or vitamins.
  • If you choose BARF, have the ration drawn up by a veterinary nutritionist and apply strict kitchen hygiene.

Bowls of raw meat, meaty bones, offal: BARF appeals to more and more owners, convinced they are giving their dog a more natural diet, closer to that of his ancestors. But what does science say about raw feeding? This guide is part of our series on feeding your dog: it explains what BARF is, what is known about its benefits and its risks, and the precautions to take if you go down this road.

What is BARF?

BARF stands for “Biologically Appropriate Raw Food”, sometimes rendered as “Bones and Raw Food”. The method was popularised in the early 1990s by the Australian vet Ian Billinghurst. The principle: feed the dog as a carnivore, with raw, unprocessed foods.

A BARF ration generally combines:

  • raw meat (muscle): beef, poultry, lamb, fish…
  • raw meaty bones, for calcium: chicken wings or carcasses, for example;
  • offal: liver, kidneys, heart;
  • a small share of blended vegetables and fruit, sometimes topped up with oils or supplements.

The proportions vary from one method to another. BARF can be prepared at home or bought as frozen raw meals sold in shops.

The claimed benefits: what the studies say

Supporters of BARF credit it with many advantages: a shinier coat, cleaner teeth, smaller stools, more energy, a stronger immune system. A review of the evidence by American veterinary nutritionists took stock[1]:

  • Only one benefit is documented: slightly better digestibility than some commercial foods. We do not know whether this difference has any effect on the dog’s health.
  • The other benefits are not demonstrated: they rest mainly on owners’ accounts.
  • The wolf argument is shaky: domestication has changed the dog’s digestion, which has moved away from that of his wild ancestor.

The authors’ conclusion is clear: given the current state of knowledge, the risks outweigh minimal benefits.

Escape instinct

Always know where he is. Live, the moment you look for him.

GPS + Galileo accurate to 5 m, a virtual fence with alerts, Europe-wide coverage. The tracker is 49 €, plus the subscription, from 13,99 €/month.

Discover the tracker
GPS tracker fitted to a dog collar

The risks of raw feeding

Bacteria and parasites

Raw meat can be contaminated with bacteria such as salmonella, E. coli or Listeria. The dog can fall ill from them, but can also carry them with no visible sign and pass them on to those around him, through his saliva or his stools. Researchers at Utrecht University analysed 35 frozen BARF products sold in the Netherlands[2]:

Bacterium or parasite Contaminated products
Listeria monocytogenes 54% (19 out of 35)
E. coli O157:H7 23% (8 out of 35)
Salmonella 20% (7 out of 35)
Toxoplasma gondii 6% (2 out of 35)

These products were sold frozen: freezing is therefore not enough to get rid of these micro-organisms. The risk affects the whole household, and above all the most vulnerable people: young children, pregnant women, older people and those with weakened immunity.

Nutritional imbalances

Putting together a complete raw ration is harder than it looks. A German study analysed 95 BARF rations prepared by owners: 60% had at least one significant imbalance[3]. The most common were:

  • iodine: about half of the rations did not provide enough;
  • zinc and copper: often insufficient;
  • calcium: too little in some rations, with an unbalanced calcium-to-phosphorus ratio, or on the contrary too much when there are too many bones;
  • vitamin A: insufficient in a quarter of the rations.

These deficiencies creep in silently: a dog can seem in perfect shape for months before problems appear.

Bones

Raw or cooked, bones can break teeth and cause a blockage or perforation of the digestive tract[1]. Cooked bones, which are more brittle, are to be ruled out in every case, as our list of foods dogs cannot eat reminds you.

Alternatives to BARF

If the idea of a more “home-made” diet appeals to you, there are other options:

The cooked home-made ration. Cooked meat, starchy foods and vegetables limit the bacterial risk, but the ration also has to be balanced and supplemented: our guide to homemade dog food explains how.

Wet food. Rich in water and appetising, it suits fussy dogs or those that drink little: see our article on wet dog food.

Dry food. Practical and complete, it remains the simplest way to a balanced diet, provided you choose well: our advice on choosing dry dog food.

Whatever diet you choose, quantity matters as much as composition: our ration calculator gives you an estimate suited to your dog’s age, weight and activity.

BARF is not a baseless fad, but its benefits remain to be demonstrated while its risks are well documented. If you are set on feeding your dog raw, do it with a veterinary nutritionist and impeccable hygiene. Otherwise, a cooked home-made ration or good dry food will give him everything he needs.

Calculer la ration de mon chien

Frequently asked questions.

Is BARF good for dogs?

Its supposed benefits (coat, teeth, energy, immunity) are not demonstrated by studies, apart from slightly better digestibility than some dry foods. Its risks, on the other hand, are documented: bacterial contamination and nutritional imbalances.

Is BARF dangerous for people?

It can be. Raw meat can contain bacteria such as salmonella, Listeria or E. coli, which can be passed to humans during preparation or by the dog himself. Young children, pregnant women, older people and those with weakened immunity are the most exposed.

Can a puppy eat BARF?

It is not recommended without veterinary supervision. A growing puppy is very sensitive to imbalances in calcium, phosphorus and vitamins, which are common in raw rations. If you want to feed him raw, the ration must be drawn up by a veterinary nutritionist.

Can you mix BARF and dry food?

It is possible, as long as the whole remains balanced and the total amount suits the dog’s needs. Ask your vet for advice on adjusting the proportions.

Does freezing kill the bacteria in raw meat?

Not all of them. In the Dutch study cited above, the products analysed were sold frozen and still contained bacteria such as Listeria, E. coli or salmonella.

Sources and references

  1. Freeman L. M., Chandler M. L., Hamper B. A., Weeth L. P. — Current knowledge about the risks and benefits of raw meat-based diets for dogs and cats, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 2013 (doi.org)
  2. van Bree F. P. J. et al. — Zoonotic bacteria and parasites found in raw meat-based diets for cats and dogs, Veterinary Record, 2018 (rivm.openrepository.com)
  3. Dillitzer N., Becker N., Kienzle E. — Intake of minerals, trace elements and vitamins in bone and raw food rations in adult dogs, British Journal of Nutrition, 2011 (cambridge.org)

This article is for information only and does not replace a vet’s advice. Before switching your dog to a raw diet, ask your vet or a veterinary nutritionist for advice.