Advice

Choosing a dog. The right questions to ask before you adopt.

  • The right dog is the one whose needs fit your daily life: time available, home, activity, grooming, who is at home.
  • Breed gives tendencies, but it is a poor predictor of an individual dog's character: a large study estimates that it explains only about 9% of differences in behaviour.
  • Puppy or adult, male or female, pedigree or crossbreed: each option has its advantages. What matters is the dog in front of you.
  • For a puppy, seeing his parents and the place where he grew up is one of the most useful pointers.

Choosing your dog is a key stage of adoption. We often have a picture in mind: a breed seen at a friend's house, a puppy spotted in a photo. Yet the companion who will make you happy, and whom you will make happy, is above all the one who will fit into your life as it is. Here are the right questions to ask yourself, and a few pointers to help you answer them.

Start with yourself, not the breed

Before you look at breeds, look at your daily life. Take a typical week and ask yourself these questions, alone or as a family:

  • How much time can you give him each day, for outings, play and care?
  • How many hours would he be alone, and who can step in?
  • Do you live in a town or in the country, in a flat or with a garden?
  • Do you enjoy hiking, sport, or more relaxed walks?
  • Are there children, other animals, or someone allergic at home?
  • What monthly budget can you give him?

Citizens Information suggests similar questions before you get a dog: does everyone in the house agree, can you afford to feed and care for him, will you have time to feed, care for and exercise him every day, will your landlord allow a dog[1]. Your answers sketch a portrait of the dog who suits you. To help you, take our quiz Which dog is right for you?.

The criteria that really matter

His need for activity

This is often the deciding factor. Herding, hunting and sled dogs were bred to work for hours: without enough physical and mental activity, they can get bored and show it through barking or destruction. Other dogs are content with calmer outings. Be honest about your real pace, not the one you would like to have.

Whatever his breed, a dog needs exercise every day: Citizens Information asks whether you will have time to feed, care for and exercise him daily[1]. If you are looking for a laid-back companion, see our selection of calm dog breeds.

His size and your home

Size matters for space, transport, budget (food, care, equipment) and your ability to carry or hold him. But a flat does not rule out a large, calm dog, and a small, very energetic dog will not necessarily be comfortable in one. The essential thing is being able to meet his need to burn off energy. We go through the breeds suited to town life in our article on the best dogs for flats.

The time he will spend alone

No dog is made to be left alone all day. The RSPCA, a British animal welfare charity, recommends not leaving a dog alone for more than four hours, and much less for a puppy[2]. If your days are long, arrange a solution now: a dog walker, daycare, a relative who is available. To understand how your dog experiences your absences, read our article on separation anxiety.

Coat care

Long hair that tangles, an undercoat that sheds in large amounts at every moult, hair that never stops growing and needs regular grooming: coat care varies enormously from breed to breed. Think about brushing time and the cost of a groomer.

If someone in the household is allergic, be wary of the promise of a “hypoallergenic” dog. A Dutch study measured the main dog allergen in hair and in homes: it found no evidence that any breed could be described as hypoallergenic, since the differences between breeds were small compared with the differences between dogs of the same breed[3]. Before you decide, spend time with the dog himself and ask an allergy specialist for advice. We take stock of dogs that do not shed and of hairless dogs, who have their own special needs too.

His health

Some breeds are more exposed to health problems linked to their build. This is the case for dogs with a very short muzzle, known as brachycephalic. The FCI Scientific Commission notes that the respiratory syndrome affecting them concerns, depending on the studies, from under 10% to 50% of dogs, with the French Bulldog, the Pug and the English Bulldog over-represented[4]. Find out about the weak points of the breed that attracts you, and ask the breeder about the health tests carried out on the parents.

His instincts

A hunting dog will often have his nose to the ground and a desire to follow a trail. A herding dog may try to round up children or bicycles. These instincts are part of him: it is better to know them so you can channel them, and to plan suitable walks if he tends to wander far. You will find each breed's characteristics in our breed guides.

Escape instinct

Always know where he is. Live, the moment you look for him.

GPS + Galileo accurate to 5 m, a virtual fence with alerts, Europe-wide coverage. The tracker is 49 €, plus the subscription, from 13,99 €/month.

Discover the tracker
GPS tracker fitted to a dog collar

Breed: a tendency, not a guarantee

Choosing a breed helps you anticipate adult size, grooming or energy level. But when it comes to character, breed does not tell the whole story. A study published in the journal Science, covering more than 18,000 dogs, estimated that breed explained only about 9% of differences in behaviour between individuals[5]. The authors conclude that it has low predictive value for any one dog. Some traits, such as how readily a dog responds to requests, are a little more closely tied to breed than others[5]. Looking for a companion to run or hike with? Browse our selection of sporty dog breeds.

In practice: use breed as a first lead, then get to know the dog himself. His history, his experiences, the way he grew up and the training he will receive will count as much as his origins. To understand better what shapes his character, read our guide to dog behaviour.

Pedigree or crossbreed?

A pedigree dog gives you a more precise idea of his adult size and coat, especially as a puppy. A crossbreed is often harder to predict on these points, but can be just as endearing a companion. In both cases, the individual's temperament comes first. If you want a pedigree dog entered in a stud book, our article on the pedigree dog explains what that guarantees, and what it does not.

Puppy or adult dog?

Puppy Adult dog
Character Still taking shape, moulded by his experiences. Already established: you know more about who you are dealing with.
Time to plan for A lot: toilet training, socialisation, first lessons, frequent presence. Variable: some already have the basics, others need time to adjust.
Size To be anticipated, especially for a crossbreed puppy. Known.
Who for? A household with time, ready to invest in the first few months. A household that wants a more predictable companion, or wants to offer a second chance.

Adopting an adult dog, or even an older one, is often a good option, especially from a rescue, where the staff know his character. If you opt for a puppy, our first-year guide takes you through it step by step.

Male or female?

The question comes up often, but a dog's own temperament generally counts for more than his sex. A few practical points can nonetheless guide your choice: an unspayed female comes into season, usually twice a year, and an unneutered male may be more drawn to females in season in the neighbourhood. Neutering changes these points: talk to your vet. If you already have a dog, how well the two characters match matters more than their sex.

Choosing a puppy from a litter

If you are adopting a puppy, take the time to meet him where he was born. Never agree to collect a puppy without first seeing him in his home environment, and a reputable breeder should be able to show you his mother. A British study published in 2012 in the Veterinary Record observed that owners who had seen neither of the puppy's parents had about four times the odds of later seeking help for a behaviour problem compared with those who had seen both[6]. The authors remain cautious: buyers who ask to see the parents may also simply be better informed.

During your visit:

  • Meet the mother, and the father if possible. Watch how they behave: are they relaxed with visitors?
  • Look at where the puppies live: a clean environment, with everyday noises, people and games. Puppies raised in an environment poor in stimulation are more exposed to behaviour problems[6].
  • Talk to the breeder or the family: how does each puppy behave? Which would suit your household best? Someone who knows his puppies well will be able to guide you.
  • Ask for the paperwork: microchip details, vaccination records, health tests on the parents for the breeds concerned.

In Ireland, a puppy can only be sold or supplied from 8 weeks. To choose the right person to deal with, read our guides on how to spot a responsible breeder and where to get a dog or puppy.

A dog for a family with children

With children, favour a patient dog, tolerant of handling and noise, and of a size suited to the age of the youngest. Here again, the individual counts for more than the breed: meet the dog with the children present before you decide. Our selection of dog breeds for children gives you some leads.

Before you decide

Is your picture of the ideal dog taking shape? Check one last time that the budget works, with our guide to the cost of owning a dog. And to go back over all the steps, from thinking it through to the paperwork, read our advice on adopting a dog.

Quiz : quelle race de chien choisir ?

Frequently asked questions.

How do I know which dog is right for me?

Start from your daily life: time available, home, activity, who is at home, children or allergies. Then look for dogs whose needs match, and meet them. Our quiz “Which dog is right for you?” can help you see more clearly.

Which dog should you choose as a first dog?

A dog with a balanced temperament, a moderate need for activity and simple grooming often makes the start easier. An adult dog whose character is known can also be a good choice.

Are there hypoallergenic dogs?

No breed truly is. Studies show that differences between dogs of the same breed are bigger than differences between breeds. Spend time with the dog himself before you decide.

Is it better to get a male or a female?

An individual's temperament generally counts for more than his sex. The female's seasons and the male's attraction to females in season are the main practical differences, which neutering changes.

How do you choose a puppy from a litter?

Meet him where he was born, with his mother if possible. Look at his surroundings and ask the breeder or the family to describe each puppy's character, so you can pick the one who fits your household.

Sources and references

  1. Citizens Information — Dog licences and ownership (citizensinformation.ie)
  2. RSPCA — Treating separation anxiety in dogs (rspca.org.uk)
  3. Vredegoor D. W., Willemse T., Chapman M. D., Heederik D. J. J., Krop E. J. M. (2012). Can f 1 levels in hair and homes of different dog breeds: lack of evidence to describe any dog breed as hypoallergenic. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 130(4), 904-909 (research-portal.uu.nl)
  4. FCI Scientific Commission — Brachycephalic breeds and brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome (BOAS), July 2020, report in French (fci.be)
  5. Morrill K. et al. (2022). Ancestry-inclusive dog genomics challenges popular breed stereotypes. Science, 376(6592) (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
  6. Westgarth C., Reevell K., Barclay R. (2012). Association between prospective owner viewing of the parents of a puppy and later referral for behavioural problems. Veterinary Record, 170(20), 517 (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)

This article is for information only. For advice suited to your situation, in particular if there is an allergy, talk to your doctor or your vet.