- “Training collars” are collars designed to correct a behaviour through discomfort: choke, half-check, prong, shock, spray.
- They work by making the behaviour unpleasant, but they do not teach the dog what to do instead.
- Veterinary behaviourists recommend reward-based methods, and studies show that even a flat collar can put risky pressure on the neck when the dog pulls.
- Our position is clear: we do not recommend any collar that works through discomfort, fear or pain, whatever the problem to be solved.
- In Ireland, the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine announced on 7 May 2024 a decision to ban hand-held remote-controlled shock collars on dogs and cats, but the regulation had not been published at 5 November 2026.
Your dog pulls on the lead, barks, won't come back, jumps up at people, and you have seen “training” collars in a pet shop or online that promise to fix the problem in a few days. Before you go ahead, it is worth knowing how they work, what risks they carry and what alternatives exist. Our aim is not to make you feel guilty, but to give you what you need to make an informed choice, in your dog's interest.
What is a training collar?
The term covers very different collars, with one thing in common: they try to change the dog's behaviour by making him feel something unpleasant (pressure, pain, a shock, a sound, a smell) at the moment he does what you want to avoid.
| Type of collar | How it works | Main risks |
|---|---|---|
| Choke collar (chain or cord) | Tightens without limit round the neck when the dog pulls or the handler jerks it | Pressure on the windpipe and neck structures, pain, risk of strangulation |
| Half-check collar (martingale) | Tightens, but only up to a limit set by a stop loop | Less risky if properly adjusted, but still puts pressure on the neck |
| Prong collar | Metal prongs pinch the neck when it tightens | Pain, wounds, neck injuries; stress and aggressive reactions |
| Shock collar | Delivers an electric shock, triggered remotely or automatically | Pain, stress, fear, damage to the relationship |
| Spray collar (citronella, air) | Squirts a jet of scent or air under the nose | Surprise, fear; triggers unrelated to the targeted behaviour |
| Vibrating or sound collar | Gives off a vibration or a beep | Can startle; variable effectiveness |
The shock collar has an article of its own: you will find the studies and the rules in our article on the shock collar.
Why they are a problem
They do not teach the right behaviour
A training collar tells the dog “not that”, but never “do this instead”. A dog who pulls and feels pressure on his neck does not know that you want him to walk beside you. At best he learns to avoid the discomfort, often only while he is wearing the collar.
They can hurt
A dog's neck houses the windpipe, the oesophagus, nerves and blood vessels. A 2020 study by Nottingham Trent University measured the pressure different collars put on a simulated neck model during a firm pull, a strong pull and a jerk. The result: none of the collars tested, including wide, padded models, applied pressure low enough to reduce the risk of injury when the dog pulls[1]. If even a flat collar carries this risk, those designed to tighten or pinch logically make it worse. RSPCA Australia, for instance, links prong collars to nerve damage, wounds and injuries to the larynx, oesophagus and windpipe[2].
They increase stress
Methods that rely on discomfort or pain are associated with more stress in dogs, and sometimes with aggressive reactions[2]. A frightened dog learns badly, and may end up linking the pain not with his behaviour but with whatever he was looking at at that moment: another dog, a child, a person. A pulling problem can then turn into a reactivity problem.
They do not treat the cause
A dog who barks from boredom, pulls from excitement or runs off for lack of exercise does not change his needs because he is given a collar. The cause is still there, and the behaviour often returns in another form.
Escape instinct
Always know where he is. Live, the moment you look for him.
GPS + Galileo accurate to 5 m, a virtual fence with alerts, Europe-wide coverage. The tracker is 49 €, plus the subscription, from 13,99 €/month.
Discover the tracker
What veterinary behaviourists say
The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), which brings together veterinarians specialising in behaviour, recommends reward-based methods for all dog training, and considers that there is no evidence that aversive methods are necessary[3]. To understand this approach, read our article on positive dog training.
What does the law say in Ireland?
On 7 May 2024, the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine announced a decision to ban the use on dogs and cats of electronic shock collars operated by hand-held remote controls. The Minister said he would introduce a regulation, and that owners already using these collars on their dogs could register those dogs with the Department so they would be exempt. The aim is to protect puppies and dogs who have never had a shock collar used on them[4]. This is an announcement, not yet a law: at 5 November 2026 we found no statutory instrument on the Irish Statute Book covering these collars, and the Department's animal welfare page, last updated on 6 July 2026, still describes the ban as a proposed regulation.
The announcement concerns hand-held remote-controlled shock collars. For the other collars in the table above, the rules are not the same: ask your local authority or your vet, and check the current rules before you buy.
Why we do not recommend training collars
Our job is to protect dogs and strengthen their bond with their family. A collar that works by making the dog feel pressure, a pinch, a shock or an unpleasant surprise runs against that idea.
- They can injure: the neck is a fragile area, and even a flat collar puts risky pressure on it when the dog pulls.
- They damage trust: the dog may link the discomfort with his owner, the lead or what he sees around him.
- They teach nothing: they tell the dog what not to do, never what to do.
- They are not necessary: veterinary behaviourists consider that reward-based methods are enough, including for difficult dogs.
We prefer to start from the dog's needs: understanding why he pulls, barks or wanders off, and teaching him what you expect. And for the times when he wanders off anyway, it is better to know where he is than to force him: that is the whole point of a GPS tracker on his collar, which protects without ever punishing.
The alternatives, by problem
Your dog pulls on the lead
A well-fitted Y-shaped harness spreads the pull across the chest rather than the neck, and makes training more comfortable[1]. Combine it with a simple method: you stop when the lead tightens, move on when it goes slack, and reward him when he walks beside you. The full method is in our article on the dog who pulls on the lead.
Your dog does not come back
Work on recall with a long line attached to a harness, rewarding every return, and keep him on the lead wherever it is needed. For the times when he wanders off anyway, a GPS tracker, suitable from 5 kg, lets you locate him.
Your dog barks
First identify why he barks: boredom, fear, alerting, frustration, loneliness. Each cause has its own solution: more physical and mental exercise, desensitisation to noises, teaching calm, work on being left alone.
Your dog jumps, mouths, can't settle
Teach him an alternative behaviour (sitting to say hello, mouthing a toy, going to his mat) and reward him. Manage the environment to limit the chances of getting it wrong.
Your dog is reactive or aggressive
This is where a training collar can do the most damage, by reinforcing the fear behind the behaviour. Call in a veterinary behaviourist or a trainer qualified in positive methods.
What about the head collar?
The head collar, which goes round the muzzle and behind the ears, guides the dog's head rather than putting pressure on the neck. Some trainers use it for very powerful dogs. It needs very gradual getting used to, because many dogs dislike it at first, and it must never be used to jerk, which can injure the neck. Ask a professional for advice before using it.
Already using a training collar?
No guilt: many owners adopted them on the advice of a salesperson or a friend, wanting to do the right thing. You can change method at any time:
- Replace it with a flat collar for the tag, and a harness for walks.
- Go back to basics in a calm environment, with plenty of rewards.
- Be patient: without the collar, some behaviours may come back at first, while he learns a new way of doing things.
- Get support from a trainer qualified in positive methods if needed.
For an overview, see our guide to dog training.



