- Positive training means rewarding the behaviours you want rather than punishing mistakes.
- It is not soft: it rests on clear rules, consistency and good management of the environment.
- Scientific studies show that punishment-based methods increase dogs' stress without being more effective.
- It suits every dog, at any age, and starts from the day a puppy arrives.
“You have to show him who's boss”, “one sharp tug on the lead and he'll get the message”: this advice, long widespread, is now widely questioned. Positive training offers another approach, based on cooperation rather than coercion. It draws on what we know about how dogs learn, and on a growing body of research. Here are its principles, what it really is (and what it is not), and how to apply it day to day.
What is positive training?
Positive training, or kind training, rests on a simple principle: a behaviour followed by something pleasant is more likely to happen again. So you reward what you want to see repeated, and you organise daily life so that the dog has few chances to get it wrong.
In practice, rather than telling off a dog who jumps up at guests, you teach him to sit to say hello, and you reward this new habit. Rather than punishing him for chewing furniture, you offer him chew toys and make the house safe.
How a dog learns
Behaviour specialists describe four ways of influencing behaviour:
| Method | Principle | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Positive reinforcement | You add something pleasant to encourage a behaviour | A treat when he sits |
| Negative punishment | You take away something pleasant to discourage a behaviour | You stop when he pulls on the lead: the walk no longer moves forward |
| Negative reinforcement | You take away something unpleasant when he does what you want | Easing pressure on the lead when he comes back to heel |
| Positive punishment | You add something unpleasant to discourage a behaviour | A jerk on the lead, a shout, a shock collar |
Positive training relies above all on positive reinforcement, supplemented if needed by negative punishment (taking away a reward, ending a game). It avoids negative reinforcement and positive punishment, which rely on discomfort, fear or pain.
What the science says
In 2021, the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), which brings together veterinarians specialising in behaviour, published a clear position statement: it recommends reward-based methods for all dog training, and states that there is no evidence that aversive methods are necessary, whether for training or for managing behaviour problems[1].
A study carried out by the University of Porto and published in 2020 compared 92 dogs trained at seven training schools, three based on reward and four on aversive methods[2]. The dogs trained with aversive methods showed more stress behaviours during sessions (lip licking, yawning, panting), spent more time in tense postures and showed a bigger rise in cortisol, the stress hormone, after training. Outside sessions, those who had received a high proportion of aversive methods were more “pessimistic” when faced with an ambiguous situation[2]. Like any study, it has its limits (a small number of dogs, in a single city), but it points the same way as the recommendations of veterinary behaviourists.
Escape instinct
Always know where he is. Live, the moment you look for him.
GPS + Galileo accurate to 5 m, a virtual fence with alerts, Europe-wide coverage. The tracker is 49 €, plus the subscription, from 13,99 €/month.
Discover the tracker
What positive training is not
It is not permissive
Positive training sets rules, and enforces them. It simply does so by teaching the dog what you expect of him, rather than punishing him for what he must not do. It often demands more rigour, in fact: consistency, regularity and good organisation.
It is not “letting him do anything”
You can say no, interrupt a behaviour, block access to something. But you do it calmly, without intimidating or hurting him, and you offer an alternative.
It is not just treats
A treat is very useful for learning, but rewards are far more varied: a game, a stroke he enjoys, praise, access to an interesting smell, the chance to greet another dog, a thrown ball. Over time, you cut back on treats and use all the rewards of everyday life.
It is not about “dominance”
The idea that a dog constantly tries to “dominate” his owner, and that you must assert yourself as “pack leader”, long justified harsh methods. It is now widely challenged by behaviour specialists: most troublesome behaviours are far better explained by fear, excitement, boredom, frustration or simply a lack of training.
The main principles day to day
1. Reward at the right moment
The reward must come immediately after the behaviour, so the dog makes the link. A “yes” or a click at the exact moment, then the treat. This is the principle of clicker training, which lets you mark good behaviour with great precision.
2. Show what you expect
A dog does not know what you expect of him until you have taught him. Guide him with a treat, break the learning into small steps, and reward every bit of progress.
3. Manage the environment
Rather than punishing after the event, you stop the mistake happening: shoes put away, a gate in front of the kitchen, a lead on walks until recall is reliable. The less a dog repeats a bad behaviour, the less it sets in.
4. Offer an alternative
A dog who jumps up at guests cannot jump and sit at the same time: teach him to sit to say hello (the method is in our article on how to stop your dog jumping up). A puppy who mouths your hands can learn to mouth a toy. You replace the troublesome behaviour with an acceptable one.
5. Ignore, sometimes
Some behaviours are kept going by the attention they get, even negative attention: barking to get noticed, jumping up to get a look. Not responding, then rewarding calm, can be enough to make them fade. Be careful: you never ignore a behaviour that puts him at risk or that shows distress.
6. Respect his emotions
A dog who is afraid, very excited or stressed learns badly. Watch his signals, reduce the difficulty, and give him time. Positive training takes account of the dog's emotional state, not just his behaviour.
7. Be consistent
The whole family must use the same words and the same rules. If the sofa is off limits one day and allowed the next, the dog cannot understand.
And what about punishment?
Shouting, shaking, jerking the lead, using a choke, prong or shock collar: these methods can seem effective in the moment, because the dog often stops what he is doing. But they carry significant risks:
- fear and stress, shown by the studies;
- a damaged relationship: the dog may link the punishment with his owner, the lead or the situation, rather than with his behaviour;
- defensive reactions: a dog who is afraid may end up growling or biting;
- incomplete learning: punishment tells him what not to do, never what to do.
To find out more about these tools and their alternatives, read our article on training collars.
Positive training for puppies
This is the ideal time to begin. A puppy has not yet picked up bad habits, and he learns very quickly. From the day he arrives, reward everything you like: he sits, he comes to you, he toilets outside, he chews his toy rather than your shoes. Manage his environment to limit mishaps, and offer him alternatives. Mistakes (toilet accidents, mouthing) are part of learning: you do not punish, you guide. You will find his first lessons in our article on puppy training.
And with an adult dog?
It is never too late. An adult dog, even one trained with other methods, can learn through reward. It sometimes takes a little more patience to undo old habits or to win back his trust. For a dog who shows fear, aggression or difficult behaviours, get support from a professional trained in positive methods: find out how to choose a dog trainer or a behaviourist.
For an overview of the lessons, see our guide to dog training.




