Advice

Dog trainer or behaviourist. Which should you choose?

Éducateur canin ou comportementaliste. Lequel choisir ?
  • A dog trainer helps you teach the basics (lead walking, recall, manners); a behaviourist works on problems such as fear, anxiety or aggression.
  • A veterinary behaviourist is the only one who can make a medical diagnosis and prescribe treatment if needed.
  • In Ireland, dog training is not a regulated profession: anyone can call themselves a trainer or a behaviourist. Check the training and the methods before you book.
  • Look for a professional who uses reward-based methods and explains what they are doing and why.

Does your dog pull on the lead so hard that every walk is exhausting, bark the moment you leave, growl at other dogs, or do you simply not know where to start with your puppy? Asking for help is not admitting defeat: it is often the quickest way forward, and it stops difficulties becoming habits. But you need to know who to turn to. Trainer, behaviourist, veterinary behaviourist: here is what each one does, when to call them and how to choose well.

Trainer, behaviourist, vet: who does what?

Professional Their role When to call them
Dog trainer Teaches you how to train your dog and supports you through everyday learning Puppy, training basics, lead walking, recall, manners, getting ready for life in town
Behaviourist Analyses the dog's behaviour in his environment and proposes a plan to work through it Fears, anxiety, destructiveness, excessive barking, difficulties living together
Veterinary behaviourist A vet trained in behavioural medicine: makes a diagnosis, looks for a medical cause and can prescribe treatment Aggression, severe anxiety, problems that persist, a sudden change in behaviour

These professionals should not be confused: a behaviourist is interested in animal psychology, whereas a veterinary behaviourist makes a medical diagnosis and puts a therapy in place. In practice, the line between trainer and behaviourist is sometimes blurred, and many professionals offer both. What counts is their training and how they work. A trainer should not advise on medical problems or serious behaviour issues: they should point you to your vet or a clinical animal behaviourist[1].

When should you call a dog trainer?

  • When a puppy arrives, to start on the right foot: toilet training, mouthing, socialisation, first commands. Group puppy classes are also an excellent option: find out what puppy school is for.
  • After adopting an adult dog, to help him find his feet and to understand him better.
  • For a stalled lesson: he pulls on the lead, he won't come back, he jumps up at people.
  • For a specific goal: living in town, using public transport, getting ready for a dog sport.
  • For you, quite simply: a first dog, a breed you don't know, the wish to do things well.

Escape instinct

Always know where he is. Live, the moment you look for him.

GPS + Galileo accurate to 5 m, a virtual fence with alerts, Europe-wide coverage. The tracker is 49 €, plus the subscription, from 13,99 €/month.

Discover the tracker
GPS tracker fitted to a dog collar

When should you see a behaviourist or a veterinary behaviourist?

  • Fear or anxiety: he trembles, hides, refuses to go out, panics at the slightest noise.
  • Difficulties when he is alone: barking, howling, destruction, accidents while you are out.
  • Aggression: growling, nipping or biting towards people or other animals. To understand the causes, read our article on the aggressive dog.
  • Sudden change in behaviour: a calm dog who becomes irritable, a house-trained dog who no longer is.
  • Problems that persist despite well-run training.

In all these cases, start with a visit to your vet: pain, a hormonal problem or an illness can be behind a change in behaviour. Your vet can then point you towards the right professional.

A special case: the behavioural assessment

After a bite, or if the authorities ask for your dog to be assessed, the assessment should be done by a suitably qualified professional. Ask your vet or your local authority's dog warden service who can carry it out.

What does a session involve?

With a dog trainer

The first session usually starts with a conversation: the dog's history, his daily life, what you expect, what is causing you problems. The trainer then watches your dog and shows you exercises to practise, which you will repeat between sessions. Sessions can be one-to-one, at home or on a training ground, or in a group. To decide which format to choose, read our article on dog training classes.

With a behaviourist or a veterinary behaviourist

The consultation is often longer, and preferably takes place where the problem occurs. The professional takes the dog's history, watches his reactions, then proposes a plan: changes to daily routine, exercises and, for a vet, sometimes medical treatment. A follow-up is generally planned to adjust the plan.

Either way, you are the one who will work with your dog every day: a good professional teaches you, and does not “fix” your dog in your place.

What the rules say

In Ireland, dog training is not a regulated profession. There is no compulsory qualification, so anyone can call themselves a dog trainer, even without the appropriate knowledge and skills, although professional bodies do assess the competence of the trainers they register[1]. The same goes for the title of behaviourist: here again, training makes all the difference.

The Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine said in 2024 that his department had no plans to introduce qualifications or regulations for dog trainers[2]. In the meantime, the choice of method is yours to check. A trainer who offers you a prong, choke or electric collar is using aversive tools, which a good professional will not recommend. To find out more, read our article on training collars.

How do you choose a good dog trainer?

The questions to ask

  • What is your training? Qualifications, courses taken, recent updates.
  • What methods do you use? A good professional answers clearly, without jargon.
  • What do you do when a dog makes a mistake? The answer says a lot about their philosophy.
  • Can I watch a session? A serious professional has nothing to hide.
  • How does the follow-up work? Number of sessions, exercises to do at home, whether you can contact them.
  • What are your fees? The price of a session varies a lot with the area, the format and the experience: see our guide to dog trainer prices.

Reassuring signs

  • They use reward-based methods, recommended by veterinary behaviourists[3].
  • They explain what they are doing and why.
  • They watch your dog's wellbeing and adapt the session if he is stressed.
  • They refer you to a vet if they suspect a medical cause.
  • They set realistic goals, without promising miracles.

Warning signs

  • They talk about “dominance”, “submission” or “showing who is boss”.
  • They use or recommend choke, prong or electric collars, lead jerks or shouting.
  • They promise guaranteed results in record time.
  • They refuse to let you watch them work with your dog.
  • Your dog seems frightened, makes himself small or tries to escape during sessions.

To understand the principles of kind training, read our article on positive dog training.

How many sessions will you need?

It all depends on the goal and on your dog. A few sessions are often enough to get started with a puppy or to fix a simple lead-walking problem. A behaviour problem that has been there a long time generally calls for longer support, over several weeks or months. In every case, it is the exercises you practise between sessions that make the difference.

Dreaming of making it your career?

Dog trainer, behaviourist, but also groomer, pet sitter, veterinary nurse: there are plenty of jobs involving dogs. Discover them in our article on jobs working with dogs.

For an overview of everything he can learn, see our guide to dog training.

Décryptez le langage de votre chien

Frequently asked questions.

What is the difference between a dog trainer and a behaviourist?

A trainer helps you with everyday learning (basics, lead walking, recall). A behaviourist works on behaviour problems such as fear, anxiety or aggression. Many professionals offer both.

When should you see a veterinary behaviourist?

For aggression, severe anxiety, a sudden change in behaviour or a problem that persists. A veterinary behaviourist is the only one who can make a medical diagnosis and prescribe treatment if needed.

Do you need a qualification to be a dog trainer?

Not in Ireland: dog training is not regulated, so anyone can use the title. Ask about the professional's training, their experience and their methods before you choose.

At what age should you call a trainer for a puppy?

As soon as he arrives. A few sessions, or puppy classes, help you start on the right foot and stop bad habits taking hold.

Can a trainer come to your home?

Yes, many offer home visits. It is often the best option for problems that show up at home, such as difficulties when the dog is alone or conflicts between pets.

What if you don't like the trainer's methods?

Trust your instincts and your dog's. You are entitled to stop the sessions and find another professional who is more in tune with your values.

Sources and references

  1. RSPCA — How to find the right dog trainer (rspca.org.uk)
  2. Houses of the Oireachtas — Written answer, Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, 21 February 2024: dog trainers (oireachtas.ie)
  3. American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) — Humane dog training position statement, 2021 (avsab.org)

This article is for information only. If your dog's behaviour changes, see your vet first.